The poem “The Man He Killed” is a very brief poem that,
despite the fact that it is merely 20 lines long, holds a big message about the
aberrant and pointless nature of war. It focuses on the relevance of circumstance
in war by stating that should the soldiers have met in any other place but on
the battle field, they likely would be friends.
As a quick history lesson, allow me to provide a tidbit of
background information on the author. Thomas Hardy is considered a “Victorian realist” due to
the fact that his writings frequently criticize social norms that hinder people’s
lives, ultimately leading to unhappiness. Hardy is a product of London, born to
Thomas and Jemima Hardy in Higher Brockhampton in 1840. Hardy never truly felt
comfortable in London, as he was conscious of class divisions and social
injustice from a young age. His writings reflect his feelings towards society,
placing emphasis on the strangeness of social norms and the status quo.
“The Man He Killed” is told from the perspective of a
soldier as he reflects on killing a man on the battle field. It’s opening stanza
creates an alternative situation in which the two opposing forces met in a
place outside of the battle field, saying they would “have sat us down to wet/
right many a nipperkin!” The sense of peace and companionship between the two
men in this imaginary circumstance differs drastically from the circumstance posed in the next
stanza, the situation that truly occurred. Instead of embracing each other as
friends, they shoot at each other, and the speaker kills the other soldier.
The speaker is torn between a feeling of justification and
guilt regarding the memory. He attempts to justify the kill, stating desperately
that he “shot him dead because-- because he was my foe” but at the same time
shows a clear sense of confusion as to why it was necessary to kill the other
man. He sees a resemblance between himself and the other soldier. He draws the
comparison on the reason why they enlisted: they were “out of work—had sold
[their traps].” The comparison between himself and the other soldier causes him
to question the purpose of the kill; it humanizes the other soldier, making him
seem just as real as the speaker or any of his comrades and therefore makes the
kill seem more like a murder than a justified act of war. The act of killing a
man that “if met where any bar is” would likely be a friend solely because it
is a war makes the war seem barbaric and pointless.
This poem is entirely demonstrative of the nature of war. It
shows how a man who would most likely be a friend or at least an acquaintance
instantly becomes an enemy for the sake of the fight. Both parties are wronged,
but neither of them can be held fully accountable for their actions because it
is a war and they are simply doing what is expected with them. They are going
with the status quo.
In any regards, Hardy's "The Man He Killed" is an extremely powerful poem that causes one to reflect on the status quo and question it.
No comments:
Post a Comment