Saturday, November 30, 2013

A Comparison of The Awakening to The Age of Innocence

I don’t typically like feminist literature. This is not because I’m against feminism or anything, as I am very obviously female and also very obviously enjoy having equal rights and opportunities. I don’t usually enjoy feminist literature for the sheer fact that I feel that it displays women as being irrational and hard headed. That’s mostly because the first work of feminist literature I ever read was Kate Chopin’s The Awakening, and my sincere and eternal hatred of Edna and her silliness kind of tainted every work of feminist literature that followed.
That being said, it should seem obvious that I wouldn’t be overjoyed when I picked up Edith Wharton’s The Age of Innocence. The novel isn’t actually a feminist work; it is actually told from a male perspective. However, simply knowing that what I was reading was going to have a strong focus on gender roles sent me into one of those oh-lord-please-not-another-Edna-esque-character state of minds. I was as happy as is to be expected from me when I started reading it.
However, once I got into the story a little bit, I found that I really liked it. It was surprisingly appealing. The novel has an interesting storyline, which despite having some similarities to that of Kate Chopin’s novel, is much more exciting. I definitely found that I can tolerate the main character a lot better (which further shows my disdain for Edna, as I don’t like Newland at all).
Though reading a plot summary of the two would make them seem like identical stories told from the perspective of different genders, there is so much variation in the plots that makes The Age of Innocence superior to The Awakening. At least, that’s how I see it.
For one thing, the main character of The Age of Innocence, the one who is engaged in a war with himself, is male. Secondly, he is not married at the opening of the novel. Where I understand that Edna being female and being a complex, thinking creature is the heart of the novel and that her not doing things she doesn’t want to do is intended to show her strength, she just seemed really silly the way I read it. It seemed kind of backwards that a book that’s supposed to demonstrate that women are more than happy housewives would make the primary character seem so weak and irrational. Edna was entirely ruled by her emotions.  She did make conscious decisions to do whatever she wanted to do regardless of social norms, which is admirable, but she did little besides that. She had an affair. She hung out in a hammock. She moved out. But she failed to show her intellectual value or her rationality  or anything besides her selfishness. 
Newland Archer is just as silly as Edna in my opinion, but for different reasons. He is overly concerned with the public opinion, he is scholarly and doesn’t miss an opportunity to show his intellectual prowess, and he is overwhelming male. Yet at the same time, he is irrational and emotional and confused. Though he is so male which would make him seem so superior compared to his fiancée or her cousin, he possess traits which make him seem, for lack of a better term, feminine.  His silliness makes him seem weak and vulnerable while making the ladies in the story seem likable by comparison: May seems like a darling but unfortunate product of the social system, while Countess Olenska seems like a disturbed, but empowered woman who has overcome adversity to reclaim her destiny. The woman in this novel seem entirely more composed than Edna. The male is the one falling apart and being silly, which makes the women seem even more admirable. The characters are much more likeable, the plot is much more realistic, and the gender dynamics are much more equal in The Age of Innocence than in The Awakening.
I will get off my soap box before this turns into an anti-Awakening rant, but once I am deeper into The Age of Innocence, I will write a more formal analysis of it.
Until then, please feel free to leave me a comment either supporting or retorting my reasoning for disliking Edna.  

No comments:

Post a Comment