Sherwood Anderson's
novel Winesburg, Ohio is a book that I probably talk about too
much. That is because it is so complex. It can be read as either a series of
short stories or a novel, seems to go out of chronological order, and leads up
to two huge, overpowering questions: 1. What did I just read? And 2. Why?
I would like to focus on
just one of the stories in it right now (though might decide to come back two
or three hours from now and attempt to analyze the other stories and tie them
to a novel as a whole). The story I want to discuss is called “Respectability.”
Firstly, let’s examine
the question of “What did I just read?”
The story centers on
Wash Williams, a dirty telegraph operator who has a strong hatred for mankind,
especially women.
This hatred for women is
rooted in Wash’s love for one woman. He was once married to a woman who he
loved dearly, however she cheated on him with multiple men. Though he is
disgusted with the act she committed, she longs to forgive her and to just put
the matter aside. However, when he visits her at her mother’s house, her mother
undresses her and pushes her into the room where he is waiting. He finds it so revolting
that he beats the girl’s mother with a chair.
And now for the “Why?”
This story is another of
Anderson’s commentaries on the difference between sex and love. Wash Williams
is so repulsed by the perversion of his love that it drives him to the hatred
of the entire sex of women. The entire story is ironic: the girl’s mother
attempts to resolve an issue that began with sex with more sex. The title, “Respectability,”
connotes high class people that are worthy of reverence, however, the family of
the girl prove to be the exact opposite of respectable. Even the main
characters name is ironic: “Wash” carries the implication of being clean,
well-kept, and unsoiled. However, the character we find is dirty on the inside
and out. He was tainted by his relations with the girl: she defiled their marriage
through adultery, which, in turn, defiled Wash (first emotionally, as he was
filled with disgust, then mentally, as his mind was made dirty with hatred).
The only indication that he was not always dirty and foul is his hands, which
he takes very good care of.
The story has depth to
it: it is more than a story about how adultery is bad and should be frowned
upon, or how the people who are the highest up in society are capable of
committing the lowest acts. It compares sex and true love, and emphasizes the
difference between the two.
In this sense, it is
similar to Anderson’s other stories. “Hands” and “Nobody Knows” both involve a
confusion between sex and love (in the former case, a teacher is accused of
molesting his students, in the latter a young lady loses her virginity to a
young man, thinking that the sexual act is a step into adulthood). However, “Respectability”
makes a deeper impact than the other stories, portraying the perversion of love
as a horrific, downright vile act.
I agree!! Wash does not want his relationship to be solved with more sex. He, unlike other men, wants a relationship that means something. He wants the relationship to rely on how they feel towards each other. It actually reminds me of "Adventure" and how Ned Currie wanted more of a physical relationship while Alice wants a "beautiful" one (Anderson 104). And what also just occured to me is how ironic it is that Wash's personality is dirty even though he's not the one who commited adultery. You'd think it would be the other way around, right? Wash's wife should be the one who has trouble with other people, not Wash, he didn't do anything wrong!
ReplyDelete