Monday, September 30, 2013

In the Room The Women Come and Go, Talking of Michelangelo: An Analysis of "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock"

There comes a rare moment while reading a fine work of literature when everything makes sense. The reader makes a connection with the piece and with the author, and experiences a moment of enlightenment. 
Anyone who has ever experienced this feeling can either empathize with me or laugh at me because that feeling is the exact inverse of what I felt while reading "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock."
In parts I struggled to understand who or what the speaker was talking about, and in other places I found myself wondering how this poem was a love song at all.
To me, it seems to be less about love and more about sex (or sexual frustration, rather). Right from the first stanza, it's all about sex. The mention of what the speaker calls "muttering retreats/ of restless nights in one-night cheap hotels/ and sawdust restaurants with oyster-shells" immediately emanates sexual desire. It is no coincidence that the shell should be that of an oyster, which is considered an aphrodisiac and is commonly associated with sex. Additionally, there are only so many reasons that a night in a cheap hotel would be restless. Perhaps the street lights seeping through the window curtains were keeping the speaker up all night, but it's doubtful. 
I wouldn't go so far as to say that the speaker is wondering through a brothel during the poem, but the lines do hold a sense of desire and frustration.  
Personally, I found the message of the poem to be an attempt to express a desire (in this case a carnal desire) and the inability to communicate that desire due to human scrutiny.
The speaker repeatedly implies that he feels exposed in the public sphere, as if he were “pinned and wriggling on the wall” like a prized insect being labeled and displayed by the “eyes that fix you in a formulated phrase.” These eyes that scrutinize and examine him are the eyes of women at parties, which indicates that he feels judged by women and does not feel able to make a connection with them. The scrutiny causes him to be nervous and to doubt himself, dwelling on unattractive details about himself such as how he is growing bald.
The scrutiny and nervousness causes him to lose all human connection that he has; he no longer has any comfort in expressing himself, so much that he feels that he is unable to express himself at all. His tie with mankind has entirely been severed.
This is my main take away for the poem, but so much more can be said! I hate focusing in on one angel and not mentioning anything else, so for brevity’s sake I will just touch on a few key aspects.
1.     The epigraph of the poem is from Dante’s Inferno, and the speaker of these lines is Guido I da Montefeltro, who was condemned to the 8th circle of hell (home to the fraudulent) for giving false counsel. The literal translation implies that the person speaking the lines is a sinner and is only telling the story because it will never be able to be retold. The use of these lines at the beginning of the poem implies that Prufrock is a sinner and has a story to tell that he is ashamed of.
2.     In the first line “Let us go then, you and I,” the personal pronouns are ambiguous. It is never clearly stated if there is a literal story teller and listener or if both the “you” and “I” are two different halves of Prufrock’s consciousness (which, in my opinion, seems more likely due to the fact that a story can definitely never be retold if you’re telling it to yourself.)
3.     None of the women in the poem are literally said to be women. They are described by their arms, eyes, dresses, and perfume, which emphasizes the feeling of dehumanization that the poem is meant to express.
     4.     Each stanza is a separate image. The poem transitions between the image of a patient         laying on a table, to a dirty city setting,  to a self-conscious middle-aged man grooming himself, etc.

No comments:

Post a Comment